SelfCritique

Why This Tool Stands Out

• Error Detection Inconsistencies, oversights, and weaknesses are identified automatically - quality assurance!
• Improvement Suggestions Concrete recommendations for every identified weakness - constructive criticism!
• Multi-Level Analysis Structure, logic, completeness, and clarity are checked - comprehensive quality control!
• Continuous Improvement Every iteration increases answer quality - a learning process!

Technical Details

Parameters

Request Example

{
  "tool": "SelfCritique",
  "params": {
    "content": "AI will replace most jobs in the future. That is good for the economy because companies save money. Workers simply have to retrain.",
    "original_question": "How will AI change the job market?",
    "critique_focus": ["accuracy", "nuance", "balance"],
    "auto_improve": true
  }
}

Response Example

{
  "status": "success",
  "critique": {
    "overall_score": 0.58,
    "issues_identified": [
      {
        "category": "Oversimplification",
        "severity": "HIGH",
        "description": "'Most jobs' is an exaggeration. Studies show: 15-30% of tasks will be automated, not 'most jobs'.",
        "suggestion": "Be specific: 'Certain repetitive tasks' or '30% of working time'"
      },
      {
        "category": "Missing Nuance",
        "severity": "MEDIUM",
        "description": "Only economic benefits mentioned, no social costs noted.",
        "suggestion": "Also address transition costs, retraining effort, social inequality"
      },
      {
        "category": "Tone",
        "severity": "MEDIUM",
        "description": "'Simply retrain' comes across as condescending toward those affected.",
        "suggestion": "Phrase more empathetically: 'Retraining is a challenge and requires government support'"
      }
    ],
    "strengths": [
      "Clear thesis",
      "Economic aspect considered",
      "Solution approach (retraining) mentioned"
    ],
    "improved_version": "AI is expected to automate 15-30% of all work tasks by 2030. While companies achieve efficiency gains, challenges arise: Affected workers need comprehensive retraining and social protection during the transition. A balanced AI strategy must combine economic benefits with social responsibility.",
    "improvement_summary": "+42% quality improvement through more nuanced presentation, a more balanced perspective, and a more empathetic tone"
  }
}

Example Usage

Illustrative HTTP pseudocode only: example.invalid is a placeholder, not a documented service endpoint. Do not send real credentials. Confirm the local MCP transport and tool schema for your installed version.

# SelfCritique API call
import requests

response = requests.post(
    "https://api.example.invalid/iqtools/selfcritique",
    headers={"Authorization": "Bearer EXAMPLE_KEY_DO_NOT_USE"},
    json={
        "content": "My proposed project plan...",
        "critique_focus": ["completeness", "feasibility"],
        "auto_improve": true
    }
)

result = response.json()
print(f"Quality score: {result['critique']['overall_score']}")
print(f"Improved version: {result['critique']['improved_version']}")

Typical Usage Examples

• Text Review

  "Critique this text and suggest improvements"

• Email Review

  "Check this email for tone and clarity"

• Document Check

  "Check this concept for completeness"

• Code Review

  "Critique this code documentation"

Perfect for

• Authors Quality review
• Communicators Tone optimization
• Managers Document review

Time Savings Overview

No measured time-saving or performance figures are available here. Results depend on the task and environment.

Related Tools

• Iterate
• Validate
• MetaReason
• BetterPrompt